Radio Silence from the American Association of Neurological Surgeons on Report of Blatant Plagiarism in Their ‘Journal of Neurosurgery’ Publication

BY SCOTT M. GRAFFIUS | ScottGraffius.com

Plagiarism in a AANS JNS Publication - Radio Silence - Creative - LwRes



black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

If there's an update after this article is published, the information will appear in the Post-Publication Notes section.

black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

Introduction

Plagiarism, defined as ‘to steal and pass off (the ideas or words of another) as one’s own: use (another's production) without crediting the source’ (source:
Merriam-Webster), damages trust, credibility, and the value of original content. The theft of intellectual property distorts the scholarly record and results in misinformation. It often violates copyright as well.

Publications must respond decisively to plagiarism reports by swiftly acknowledging complaints, conducting thorough investigations, and taking appropriate actions such as retractions.

black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

Quiz Question

The visual at the top of this article depicts a quiz related to a real situation. Here's the question:

You discovered blatant plagiarism in a Journal of Neurosurgery publication of the American Association of Neurological Surgeons. You reported it—with detailed specifics and indisputable evidence—to the authors, the editors, and the publisher. What should happen next (within five business days)?

๐Ÿ”˜ A. The publisher or one or more of the authors or editors replies with, “Thank you for alerting us about the violation; we’re looking into it.”

๐Ÿ”˜ B. The publisher or one or more of the authors or editors challenges you to a duel to defend their honor.

๐Ÿ”˜ C. Neither the publisher nor any of the authors or editors responds. Radio silence.

black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

Quiz Answer

The question is about what should happen. For that reason, the correct answer about what should happen is: 'A. The publisher or one or more of the authors or editors replies with, "Thank you for alerting us about the violation; we're looking into it."

When publications receive a report of plagiarism, they should promptly acknowledge receipt of the report by responding within no longer than five business days. This action demonstrates transparency, professionalism, and a commitment to maintaining the integrity of the academic record. Conversely, not expeditiously acknowledging receipt of the report conveys a lack of transparency, a lack of professionalism, and a lack of commitment to integrity.

black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

Radio Silence by the Publisher, the Editors, and the Authors

It would be nice if the quiz above was just a hypothetical/thought experiment. Unfortunately, it's related to the real situation where Scott M. Graffius discovered blatant plagiarism in a Journal of Neurosurgery publication of the American Association of Neurological Surgeons and notified the authors, the editors, and the publisher of the violation on 24 September 2024.

As mentioned earlier, publishers should promptly acknowledge receipt of plagiarism reports by responding within no longer than five business days. As of the date of this article (8 October 2024), 10 business days (14 calendar days) have elapsed since the violation was reported. And the publisher, the editors, and the authors maintain radio silence.

Plagiarism is bad. By not acknowledging receipt of the report, the publisher, the editors, and the authors made the bad situation worst. And the publisher (JNS Publishing Group / American Association of Neurological Surgeons) has not yet taken action such as retraction or removal of the infringing material.

Radio Silence from the American Association of Neurological Surgeons on Report of Blatant Plagiarism in Their Journal of Neurosurgery - Excerpt - LwRes

It is imperative that the publisher demonstrate—through their actions—a commitment to upholding the highest standards of ethics and intellectual property rights. The publisher must take immediate and decisive action such as retracting or removing the infringing content. Otherwise, the publisher is knowingly endorsing, permitting or otherwise allowing ongoing misinformation and the perpetual violation of Graffius' intellectual property.

Details follow. If there's an update on this consequential matter after this article is published, the information will appear in the Post-Publication Notes section.

black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

Plagiarism in a AANS JNS Publication - Fingers Grab Grabbing Stealing IP Intellectual Property - LwRes

Details on the Plagiarism

On 24 September 2024, Scott M. Graffius observed plagiarism in a
Journal of Neurosurgery (JNS) publication of the American Association of Neurological Surgeons. That same day, Graffius wrote to the publisher, the editors, and the authors of the violating material. His email was titled, 'JNS paper plagiarized and damaged the marketability and value of Scott M. Graffius’ copyrighted property.' It contained detailed specifics and indisputable evidence. Saved as a PDF, Graffius' email is 19 pages.

As a high-level overview, thumbnails of the 19-page email are shown below. Then, select 'readable' excerpts are provided.

Graffius v JNSPG AANS UM JNS Muhlestein Chang Justice Johnson Brown Popadich - Blg Exhibit - Big Thumbnail

Excerpts from Graffius' 19-page email follow. They're shown in italic font.

Here's an excerpt from the introduction section of Graffius' email.

Authors of a Journal of Neurosurgery (JNS) paper plagiarized Graffius’ copyrighted ‘Phases of Team Development’ property, constituting a profound and disgraceful breach of professional ethics, moral standards, and Graffius’ intellectual property rights. Here are the specifics on the publication.

  • Publication: Journal of Neurosurgery
  • Publisher: JNS Publishing Group, American Association of Neurological Surgeons
  • Paper: Developing interdisciplinary research teams in neurosurgery: key elements to success in brachial plexus and peripheral nerve surgery
  • Authors: Whitney E. Muhlestein, MD; Kate W. C. Chang, MA, MS; Denise Justice, OTRL, Sarah Johnson, MS, OTRL; Shawn Brown; and Miriana Popadich, MSN, NP-C
  • Publication Date: 12 May 2023
  • Volume/Issue: Volume 139: Issue 6
  • Page Range: 1552-1559
  • DOI link: https://doi.org/10.3171/2023.4.JNS222254

Here's an excerpt from the section of the email with background information.

Informed by the research of Bruce W. Tuckman, Ph.D. and Mary Ann C. Jensen, over 100 subsequent studies, and Scott M. Graffius’ first-hand professional experience with, and analysis of, team leadership and performance, Graffius created his ‘Phases of Team Development.’ It’s a unique perspective on the five phases of team development — Forming, Storming, Norming, Performing, and Adjourning — and it’s inclusive of the characteristics/features/traits and strategies for each phase.

Graffius’ ‘Phases of Team Development’ intellectual property is registered with the United States Copyright Office.

The integrated text from Graffius’ copyrighted property applies in this case.

Graffius initially developed his intellectual property in 2008, and he periodically refreshes it. An authorized example of his copyrighted property applicable in this case (2022 edition) is here: https://www.scottgraffius.com/blog/files/teams- 2022.html .

Here's more from the section of the email with background information.

Graffius’ copyright ownership details are integrated into and appear on his copyrighted property. Specifically, it reads: “Copyright © 2008-2022 Scott M. Graffius. All rights reserved. For permission requests, contact scott@scottgraffius.com.”

Additionally, his respective article includes this: “To request permission to use the 'Phases of Team Development' visual, contact Scott M. Graffius. If approved, high resolution JPG and PNG image files will be provided, subject to terms and conditions.”

And also this: “© Copyright 2022 Scott M. Graffius. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without the express written permission of Scott M. Graffius.”

Conference organizers, businesses, professional associations, government agencies, and universities around the world engage Graffius to deliver compelling talks and workshops. To date, he’s presented sessions at 91 conferences and other events across 25 countries, including:

  • Armenia,
  • Australia,
  • Brazil,
  • Canada,
  • Czech Republic,
  • Finland,
  • France,
  • Germany,
  • Greece,
  • Hong Kong,
  • Hungary,
  • India,
  • Ireland,
  • Lithuania,
  • Luxembourg,
  • Nepal,
  • Netherlands,
  • New Zealand,
  • Norway,
  • Romania,
  • Sweden,
  • Switzerland,
  • United Arab Emirates,
  • United Kingdom,
  • and the United States.

Graffius’ ‘Phases of Team Development’ intellectual property is central and key to many of those sessions. His rate card and a listing of his engagements are at https://scottgraffius.com/resources/Exceptional-PPM-and-PMO-Solutions- Rate-Card-for-2024-2025-v24071607.pdf and https://scottgraffius.com/publicspeaker.html, respectively.

With an authorization/license from Graffius, many organizations around the world have featured and used his copyrighted ‘Phases of Team Development’ work. Select examples include:

  • Adobe,
  • American Management Association,
  • Amsterdam Public Health Research Institute,
  • Boston University,
  • Broadcom,
  • Cisco,
  • Deimos Aerospace,
  • DevOps Institute,
  • Erste Group Bank AG (Austria),
  • FINAT,
  • Ford Motor Company,
  • FSU College of Medicine,
  • Hasso Plattner Institute (Germany),
  • IEEE,
  • Johns Hopkins University,
  • LeadingEng,
  • London South Bank University,
  • Manufacturers Alliance,
  • Microsoft,
  • New Zealand Government,
  • Oracle,
  • Royal Australasian College of Physicians,
  • TBS Switzerland,
  • Torrens University (Australia),
  • Tufts University,
  • U.S. National Park Service,
  • U.S. Tennis Association,
  • UC San Diego,
  • UK Sports Institute,
  • University of Galway (Ireland),
  • Victorian Institute of Technology (Australia),
  • Virginia Tech,
  • Warsaw University,
  • Western Sydney University (Australia),
  • World Resources Institute,
  • Yale University,
  • ZHAW Zurich University of Applied Sciences,
  • and many others.

The following excerpts are from the section of the email detailing the violation.

Again, Graffius’ copyright ownership details and permission request information are clearly noted.

Authors (Whitney E. Muhlestein, MD; Kate W. C. Chang, MA, MS; Denise Justice, OTRL, Sarah Johnson, MS, OTRL; Shawn Brown; and Miriana Popadich, MSN, NP-C) of the JNS paper (
'Developing interdisciplinary research teams in neurosurgery: key elements to success in brachial plexus and peripheral nerve surgery') did not request nor receive permission to use Graffius’ copyrighted property.

Nevertheless, the authors used Graffius’ copyrighted property in their JNS article: they plagiarized Graffius’ work, damaging the marketability and value of his intellectual property.

The following excerpts from the email provide some side-by-side examples of Graffius' copyrighted property and the plagiarism in the JNS publication.

  • Content from Scott M. Graffius 2022 copyrighted property: “High motivation, trust, and empathy”
  • Content from 2023 JNS article, plagiarizing Graffius’ work: “High motivation, trust, and empathy”

  • Content from Scott M. Graffius 2022 copyrighted property: “Individuals defer to team needs”
  • Content from 2023 JNS article, plagiarizing Graffius’ work: “Individuals defer to team needs”

  • Content from Scott M. Graffius 2022 copyrighted property: “Effectively producing deliverables”
  • Content from 2023 JNS article, plagiarizing Graffius’ work: “Effectively producing deliverables”

  • Content from Scott M. Graffius 2022 copyrighted property: “Consistent performance”
  • Content from 2023 JNS article, plagiarizing Graffius’ work: “Consistent performance”

  • Content from Scott M. Graffius 2022 copyrighted property: “Demonstrations of interdependence”
  • Content from 2023 JNS article, plagiarizing Graffius’ work: “Demonstrations of interdependence”

  • Content from Scott M. Graffius 2022 copyrighted property: “Purpose and goals are well-understood”
  • Content from 2023 JNS article, plagiarizing Graffius’ work: “Purpose and goals are well-understood”

  • Content from Scott M. Graffius 2022 copyrighted property: “More confident”
  • Content from 2023 JNS article, plagiarizing Graffius’ work: “More confidence”

  • Content from Scott M. Graffius 2022 copyrighted property: “Members are engaged and supportive”
  • Content from 2023 JNS article, plagiarizing Graffius’ work: “Members are engaged and supportive”

The exhibit below also shows some examples of the blatant plagiarism.

Graffius v JNSPG AANS UM JNS Muhlestein Chang Justice Johnson Brown Popadich - Blg Exhibit - SideBySide

The following excerpts are from the conclusion section of Graffius' email.

Graffius’ copyright ownership details are integrated into and appear on his copyrighted property. Specifically, it reads: “Copyright © 2008-2022 Scott M. Graffius. All rights reserved. For permission requests, contact scott@scottgraffius.com.” Additionally, his article includes this: “To request permission to use the 'Phases of Team Development' visual, contact Scott M. Graffius. If approved, high resolution JPG and PNG image files will be provided, subject to terms and conditions.” And also this: “© Copyright 2022 Scott M. Graffius. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without the express written permission of Scott M. Graffius.”

Authors (Whitney E. Muhlestein, MD; Kate W. C. Chang, MA, MS; Denise Justice, OTRL, Sarah Johnson, MS, OTRL; Shawn Brown; and Miriana Popadich, MSN, NP-C) of the JNS paper (Developing interdisciplinary research teams in neurosurgery: key elements to success in brachial plexus and peripheral nerve surgery) did not request nor receive permission to use Graffius’ copyrighted property.

The authors of the JNS paper used Graffius’ copyrighted property, including plagiarizing it. The JNS paper did not attribute material to Graffius through citation or otherwise. By doing so, the authors are wrongly leading others to falsely believe that they are the author and owner of Graffius’ respective copyrighted content.

The JNS authors’ plagiarism damaged the marketability and value of Graffius’ copyrighted property.

The aforementioned actions of the authors of the JNS paper are a disgraceful breach of professional ethics, moral standards, and Graffius’ intellectual property rights.

The following excerpt is also from the conclusion section of Graffius' email.

Graffius maintains, enforces, and protects his copyright and other intellectual property rights. He is consulting with an IP attorney in Los Angeles. Graffius reserves his rights in this disturbing and consequential matter.

The preceding provided excerpts of key content—not the full transcript—of Graffius' email.

Authors of the
Journal of Neurosurgery (JNS) paper blatantly plagiarized Graffius’ copyrighted ‘Phases of Team Development’ property, constituting a profound and disgraceful breach of professional ethics, moral standards, and Graffius’ intellectual property rights.

It is shocking that neither the publisher nor any of the editors or authors have responded to Graffius' report on the violation. By not acknowledging receipt of the plagiarism report, the publisher signals a lack of transparency, a lack of professionalism, and a lack of commitment to integrity.

It is imperative that the publisher, JNS Publishing Group / the American Association of Neurological Surgeons, demonstrate—through their actions—a commitment to upholding the highest standards of ethics and intellectual property rights. The publisher must take immediate and decisive action such as retracting or removing the infringing content. Otherwise, they risk losing their credibility and the trust placed in them by scientific and academic communities.

If there's an update after this article is published, the information will appear in the Post-Publication Notes section.

Read on to learn:

  • About the Journal of Neurosurgery,
  • About the American Association of Neurological Surgeons,
  • About Scott M. Graffius,
  • References/Sources,
  • How to Cite This Article,
  • Post-Publication Notes,
  • and more.

black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

About the Journal of Neurosurgery

The
Journal of Neurosurgery (JNS) is a monthly peer-reviewed medical journal covering all aspects of neurosurgery. It is published by the American Association of Neurological Surgeons (AANS) and the editor-in-chief is James Rutka. The JNS brands itself as the world’s leading journal on neurosurgery and the official journal of the AANS.

Visit the
JNS website to learn more.

Note: Scott M. Graffius included (among others) James Rutka, AANS Editor-in-Chief, on the 24 September 2024 email detailing the plagiarism violation.

black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

About the American Association of Neurological Surgeons


The American Association of Neurological Surgeons (AANS) is dedicated to advancing neurological surgery. The AANS says that through rigorous education, groundbreaking research, robust advocacy, and the advancement of outcomes science, it strives to ensure the highest standards of patient care are met and exceeded.
Katie O. Orrico is Chief Executive Officer of the AANS.

Visit the
AANS website to learn more.

Note: Scott M. Graffius included (among others) Katie O. Orrico, AANS CEO, on the 24 September 2024 email detailing the plagiarism violation.

black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

About Scott M. Graffius


Scott_M_Graffius_-_Blue_-_1000x1000_-LwRes

Scott M. Graffius is a global leader in agile project management, an expert on teamwork tradecraft, an authority on temporal dynamics on social media platforms, a creator, a consultant, a trainer, an award-winning author, and an international public speaker.

He's generated over $1.9 billion of business value in aggregate for Global Fortune 500 businesses and other organizations he's served — as a consultant through
Exceptional PPM and PMO Solutions and Exceptional Agility, and as a member of staff at organizations. Businesses and industries range from consumer products to advanced technology (including AI, R&D), e-commerce, music, streaming/OTT video, television, film, video games, financial services, government, and more.

Graffius and content from his books (
Agile Scrum and Agile Transformation), talks, workshops, and more have been featured and used by businesses, professional associations, governments, and universities around the world. Examples include Adobe, American Management Association, Amsterdam Public Health Research Institute, Bayer, Boston University, Broadcom, Cisco, Deimos Aerospace, DevOps Institute, EU's European Commission, Ford Motor Company, Hasso Plattner Institute Germany, IEEE, Johns Hopkins University, London South Bank University, Microsoft, National Academy of Sciences, New Zealand Government, Oracle, Project Management Institute, Torrens University Australia, UC San Diego, TBS Switzerland, UK Sports Institute, University of Galway Ireland, U.S. Department of Energy, U.S. National Park Service, U.S. Tennis Association, Virginia Tech, Warsaw University of Technology, Yale University, Zurich University of Applied Sciences, and many others.

He delights audiences around the world with dynamic and engaging talks and workshops. He's presented sessions at 91 conferences and other events across 25 countries. Visit
here to learn more and here to ask Scott to speak at your event.

Scott M Graffius on X - SG on X Design 2 - v Feb 7 2024 - LwRes

Scott M Graffius - Impact_com Platform for Influencers and Affiliates - v April 7 2024 - rev April 10 2024 - LwRes

black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

About Agile Scrum: Your Quick Start Guide with Step-by-Step Instructions

Scott_M_Graffius_Agile_Scrum_v22123007_LR_1000x1000_sq

Shifting customer needs are common in today's marketplace. Businesses must be adaptive and responsive to change while delivering an exceptional customer experience to be competitive.

There are a variety of frameworks supporting the development of products and services, and most approaches fall into one of two broad categories: traditional or agile. Traditional practices such as waterfall engage sequential development, while agile involves iterative and incremental deliverables. Organizations are increasingly embracing agile to manage projects, and best meet their business needs of rapid response to change, fast delivery speed, and more.

With clear and easy to follow step-by-step instructions,
Scott M. Graffius's award-winning Agile Scrum: Your Quick Start Guide with Step-by-Step Instructions helps the reader:

  • Implement and use the most popular agile frameworkโ€•Scrum;
  • Deliver products in short cycles with rapid adaptation to change, fast time-to-market, and continuous improvement; and
  • Support innovation and drive competitive advantage.

Hailed by Literary Titan as “the book highlights the versatility of Scrum beautifully.”

Winner of 17 first place awards.

Agile Scrum: Your Quick Start Guide with Step-by-Step Instructions is available in paperback and ebook/Kindle in the United States and around the world. Some links by country follow.



black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

About
Agile Transformation: A Brief Story of How an Entertainment Company Developed New Capabilities and Unlocked Business Agility to Thrive in an Era of Rapid Change

Scott_M_Graffius_Agile_Transformation_LR_1000x505

Thriving in today's marketplace frequently depends on making a transformation to become more agile. Those successful in the transition enjoy faster delivery speed and ROI, higher satisfaction, continuous improvement, and additional benefits.

Based on actual events,
Agile Transformation: A Brief Story of How an Entertainment Company Developed New Capabilities and Unlocked Business Agility to Thrive in an Era of Rapid Change provides a quick (60-90 minute) read about a successful agile transformation at a multinational entertainment and media company, told from the author's perspective as an agile coach.

The award-winning book by
Scott M. Graffius is available in paperback and ebook/Kindle in the United States and around the world. Some links by country follow.



black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

scott_m_graffius_-_blog_spacer_-_v23111107_-_references

References/Sources


The following is a list of material on publishing standards and procedures. Some cover the reporting and handling of plagiarism.

  1. Alter, Alexandra (2019, September 22). It’s a Fact: Mistakes are Embarrassing the Publishing Industry. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/09/22/business/publishing-books-errors.html.
  2. American Psychological Association (2019, November). Correction Notices. Available at: https://apastyle.apa.org/style-grammar-guidelines/research-publication/correction-notices.
  3. Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) (2018, November 15). ACM Publications Policy on the Withdrawal, Correction, Retraction, and Removal of Works from ACM Publications and ACM DL. Available at: https://www.acm.org/publications/policies/retraction-policy.
  4. Cambridge University Press (n.d.). Publishing Ethics. Available at: https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/flow/information/journal-policies/publishing-ethics.
  5. Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) (n.d.). Post-Publication Discussions and Corrections. Available at: https://publicationethics.org/postpublication.
  6. Elsevier (n.d.). Policy and Best practice: Errata & Corrigenda. Available at: https://www.elsevier.com/editor/perk/policy-and-best-practice-errata-and-corrigenda.
  7. Emerald Publishing (n.d.). Article Withdrawal & Correction. Available at: https://www.emeraldgrouppublishing.com/publish-with-us/author-policies/article-withdrawal-correction.
  8. Faust, Jessica (2007, October 3). Typos and Errors After Publication. Available at: https://bookendsliterary.com/typos-and-errors-after-publication.
  9. Graffius, Scott M. (2024, March 22). The Protocol for Reporting an Error to an Author or Publisher. Available at: https://scottgraffius.com/blog/files/error-reporting.html. DOI: 10.13140/RG.2.2.18830.98883.
  10. Graffius, Scott M. (2021, November 10). An Error Was Introduced Into the Seventh Edition of 'A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge (PMBOK)'. Available at: https://scottgraffius.com/blog/files/pmbok7.html.
  11. Idunn (n.d.). Publishing and Research Ethics Policy. Available at: https://www.idunn.no/info/publiseringsetikk.
  12. IEEE (n.d.). Publishing Ethics: Guidelines and Policies: Post-Publication Policies. Available at: https://books.ieeeauthorcenter.ieee.org/book-publishing-at-ieee/publishing-ethics/guidelines-and-policies/post-publication-policies.
  13. Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) (n.d.). Guidelines for Ethical Behavior in Publishing. Available at: https://pubsonline.informs.org/page/opre/guidelines-for-ethical-behavior-in-publishing.
  14. IntechOpen (n.d.). Retraction and Correction Policy. Available at: https://www.intechopen.com/page/retraction-and-correction-policy.
  15. Marasoviฤ‡, Tea; Utrobiฤ‰iฤ‡, Ana; and Maruลiฤ‡, Ana (2018, March 31). Transparency of Retracting and Replacing Articles. The Lancet, 391 (10127): 1244-1245.
  16. Nature (n.d.). Editorial and Publishing Policies. Available at: https://www.nature.com/srep/journal-policies/editorial-policies.
  17. O’Reilly Media (n.d.). Errata for Java in a Nutshell. Available at: https://www.oreilly.com/catalog/errata.csp?isbn=0636920030775.
  18. Palgrave Macmillan (n.d.). Corrections and Retractions. Available at: https://www.palgrave.com/gp/editorial-policies/corrections-and-retractions.
  19. Pearson Education / InformIT (n.d.). Contact Us: Submit Errata. Available at: https://www.informit.com/about/contact_us/index.aspx?ContactUs_Topics_Partners_id=9d39709c-c911-4c96-ac2c-2c5a22d68ba9.
  20. Project Management Institute (PMI) (n.d.). PMI Standards Program Comment Form. Available at: https://www.pmi.org/-/media/pmi/documents/public/pdf/pmbok-standards/pmi-standards-program-comment-form.pdf.
  21. Project Management Institute (PMI) (n.d.). Standards Errata Sheets. Available at: https://www.pmi.org/pmbok-guide-standards/foundational/pmbok/errata-sheets.
  22. Public Library of Science (PLOS) (n.d.). Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and Retractions. Available at: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/s/corrections-and-retractions.
  23. SAE International (n.d.). ARINC Standard – Errata Report Template. Available at: https://wcm14.sae.org/site/binaries/content/assets/itc/content/arinc/errata-form.docx [note: selecting the link will download the file].
  24. Sage Publications (n.d.). Sage Corrections and Retractions Policy. Available at: https://us.sagepub.com/en-us/nam/sage-corrections-and-retractions-policy.
  25. Science Publishing Group (n.d.). Ethical Guidelines. Available at: https://www.sciencepublishinggroup.com/information/ethical-guidelines.
  26. Springer (n.d.). Editorial Policies: Corrections and Retractions. Available at: https://www.springer.com/gp/editorial-policies/corrections-and-retractions.
  27. Taylor & Francis (n.d.). Publishing Ethics for Journal Editors: FAQs. Available at: https://editorresources.taylorandfrancis.com/publishing-ethics-for-editors/publishing-ethics-faqs.
  28. Ubiquity Press (n.d.). Correction and Retraction Policy. Available at: https://ubiquitypress.com/site/corrections.
  29. Warner, Brooke (2019, April 26). How to Publish a Perfect Book. Available at: https://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/authors/pw-select/article/79902-how-to-publish-a-perfect-book.html.
  30. Wiley (n.d.). Best Practice Guidelines on Research Integrity and Publishing Ethics. Available at: https://authorservices.wiley.com/ethics-guidelines/index.html.
  31. Wiley Author Services (n.d.). Wiley's Policy for Handling Retractions, Withdrawals, and Expressions of Concern. Available at: https://authorservices.wiley.com/ethics-guidelines/retractions-and-expressions-of-concern.html.
  32. World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) (n.d.). Managing Intellectual Property in the Book Publishing Industry. Available at: https://www.wipo.int/edocs/pubdocs/en/copyright/868/wipo_pub_868.pdf.

black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

scott_m_graffius_-_blog_spacer_-_v23111107_-_cite

How to Cite This Article


Graffius, Scott M. (2024, October 8). Radio Silence from the American Association of Neurological Surgeons on Report of Blatant Plagiarism in Their ‘Journal of Neurosurgery’ Publication. Available at:
https://scottgraffius.com/blog/files/aans-jns-publication.html. DOI: 10.13140/RG.2.2.25837.40160

black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

spacer-post-publication-notes-1000pxw

Post-Publication Notes

If there are any supplements or updates to this article after the date of publication, they will appear here.

Update on 11 October 2024

As a recap, Graffius’ 24 September 2024 report provided indisputable proof of plagiarism. Graffius emailed the detailed report to the publisher, the editors, and the authors. However, weeks passed with radio silence. There was not even an acknowledgement of receipt of the report.

Graffius maintains, enforces, and protects his copyright and other intellectual property rights. The publisher’s non-response signaled that they were knowingly endorsing, permitting or otherwise allowing ongoing misinformation and the perpetual violation of Graffius' intellectual property. For those reasons, Graffius expanded communications on this consequential matter.
Here's one example (of many).

On 11 October 2024, the publisher sent their first response to Graffius. Here’s an excerpt from the publisher’s email (it appears in italic font, within quotation marks):

“Thank you for your email and your patience as we have looked into this matter. We have concluded our investigation. The author did indeed unintentionally include unattributed references to your work. An erratum and article correction by the author are in process. Once submitted to us, time to publication is usually 2-3 weeks. I would expect this process to be concluded in less than 4 weeks’ time. I will send you a link to the errata and corrected paper for your files once they have been published online.”

Again, the above is an excerpt from—not a full transcript of—the publisher’s email to Graffius.

The publisher used the term “unintentionally.” That term, whether referencing a ridiculous excuse of the plagiarizing authors or otherwise, is counter-indicated by the undeniable facts in this serious matter and should not be used. For that reason, Graffius responded to the publisher’s email the same day. Here’s an excerpt from Graffius’ email (it appears in italic font, within quotation marks):

“Your response warrants a reply. So here it is.

I will not re-state my full 24 September 2024* report of the indisputable facts. But here’s an excerpt:

๐ŸŸข Content from Scott M. Graffius 2022 copyrighted property: “High motivation, trust, and empathy”
๐Ÿ”ด Content from 2023 JNS article, plagiarizing Graffius’ work: “High motivation, trust, and empathy”

๐ŸŸข Content from Scott M. Graffius 2022 copyrighted property: “Individuals defer to team needs”
๐Ÿ”ด Content from 2023 JNS article, plagiarizing Graffius’ work: “Individuals defer to team needs”

๐ŸŸข Content from Scott M. Graffius 2022 copyrighted property: “Effectively producing deliverables”
๐Ÿ”ด Content from 2023 JNS article, plagiarizing Graffius’ work: “Effectively producing deliverables”

๐ŸŸข Content from Scott M. Graffius 2022 copyrighted property: “Consistent performance”
๐Ÿ”ด Content from 2023 JNS article, plagiarizing Graffius’ work: “Consistent performance”

๐ŸŸข Content from Scott M. Graffius 2022 copyrighted property: “Demonstrations of interdependence”
๐Ÿ”ด Content from 2023 JNS article, plagiarizing Graffius’ work: “Demonstrations of interdependence”

๐ŸŸข Content from Scott M. Graffius 2022 copyrighted property: “Purpose and goals are well-understood”
๐Ÿ”ด Content from 2023 JNS article, plagiarizing Graffius’ work: “Purpose and goals are well-understood”

๐ŸŸข Content from Scott M. Graffius 2022 copyrighted property: “More confident”
๐Ÿ”ด Content from 2023 JNS article, plagiarizing Graffius’ work: “More confidence”

๐ŸŸข Content from Scott M. Graffius 2022 copyrighted property: “Members are engaged and supportive”
๐Ÿ”ด Content from 2023 JNS article, plagiarizing Graffius’ work: “Members are engaged and supportive”

My copyright ownership details are integrated into and appear on my copyrighted ‘Phases of Team Development’ property. Specifically, it reads: ‘Copyright © 2008-2022 Scott M. Graffius. All rights reserved. For permission requests, contact scott@scottgraffius.com.’ Additionally, my corresponding publication includes this: ‘© Copyright 2022 Scott M. Graffius. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without the express written permission of Scott M. Graffius.’

Authors (Whitney E. Muhlestein, MD; Kate W. C. Chang, MA, MS; Denise Justice, OTRL, Sarah Johnson, MS, OTRL; Shawn Brown; and Miriana Popadich, MSN, NP-C) of the JNS paper ('Developing interdisciplinary research teams in neurosurgery: key elements to success in brachial plexus and peripheral nerve surgery') did not request nor receive permission to use my copyrighted property.

Plagiarism is defined as ‘to steal and pass off (the ideas or words of another) as one’s own: use (another's production) without crediting the source’ (source: Merriam-Webster). It infringes on the intellectual property rights of others, results in misinformation, and often violates copyright.

The authors of the JNS paper used my copyrighted property, including plagiarizing it. Most of their plagiarism was word-for-word use of my intellectual property.

The JNS paper did not attribute material to me through citation or otherwise. By doing so, the authors are wrongly leading others to falsely believe that they are the author and owner of my respective copyrighted content.

So, these author(s)—who have been proven to be plagiarizers—claim the violation was done “unintentionally”? They unintentionally took my copyrighted property and used it (mostly word-for-word) unintentionally, and unintentionally failed to credit me on their respective diagram, and also unintentionally failed to cite me in the references section of the paper? The authors are insulting others with their excuse. “Unintentionally” is a ridiculous and desperate attempt to ‘minimize’ or ‘spin’ their blatant violation. I reject it entirely and so should you.

Wouldn’t it be refreshing to see the proven plagiarizers take a nice turn and demonstrate integrity, sincerity, and remorse?! They could have, and should have, simply said that what they did was wrong. However, by asserting “unintentionally,” the authors are demonstrating an ongoing lack of integrity, sincerity, and remorse. I must say, I’m greatly concerned.

Maybe the authors are procedurally allowed to (falsely) claim whatever they want, including “unintentionally,” in their response to the charges. However, if “unintentionally” (or a similar term) appears in the official record—whether in an erratum, retraction, or other action—it must be noted that “unintentionally” (or a similar term) is the claim of the authors of the JNS paper. It is vital that the that it is made clear that “unintentionally” (or a similar operative term) is not the conclusion or position of others. Here, 'others' includes me. Given the facts and without bias, ‘others’ certainty also includes you, the Journal of Neurosurgery, JNS Publishing Group, the American Association of Neurological Surgeons, and others.

Plagiarism is a profound and disgraceful breach of professional ethics, moral standards, and intellectual property rights. The authors of the JNS paper damaged the marketability and value of my copyrighted property.

I maintain, enforce, and protect my copyright and other intellectual property rights. As mentioned earlier, I am consulting with an IP attorney in Los Angeles. I reserve my rights in this disturbing and consequential matter.

Given the serious nature of this issue, please reply with a short confirmation that you received this communication.”


Again, the above is an excerpt from—not a full transcript of—Graffius’ email to the publisher.

The publisher replied the same day with (it appears in italic font, within quotation marks):

“That word was solely mine, and not a reflection of what will be conveyed. You are correct that it is irrelevant to the discussion. Apologies for the miscommunication. Please be assured we do not take this situation lightly. Acknowledging receipt of your correspondence with this email. I will be back in touch soon.”

Again, the above is an excerpt from—not a full transcript of—the publisher’s email to Graffius.

Any further updates will appear here.

Update on 12 November 2024

On 12 November 2024, Graffius sent a follow up email to the publisher. Here's an excerpt from the message (it appears in italic font, within quotation marks):

"Chief Publications Officer Gillian Shasby,

Until the infringing article is appropriately addressed, it continues to spread misinformation and violate my intellectual property rights.

I provided notification of the infringement on 24 September (which may have appeared a few minutes into the following day). That was 49 days ago.

On 11 October, I was informed that: “... expect this process to be concluded in less than 4 weeks’ time.” That was 32 days (4.6 weeks) ago.

Why hasn’t this been addressed?

Exactly when will it be addressed?

I expressly reserve all rights in this troubling, damaging, and consequential matter.

Sincerely,

Scott M. Graffius"

Any further updates will appear here.

Update on 15 November 2024

Chief Publications Officer Gillian Shasby sent an email to Graffius. The email reported that:

  • The publisher will rectify the current lack of attribution and correct the scientific record by updating the legend to Figure 3 and add Graffius’ work to the References.
  • The publisher will publish an Erratum, stating that permission was not received and proper attribution was not given for the use of copyrighted material in Figure 3 of the paper and that permission has now been received and correctly attributed, and will include a link to the corrected paper. The Erratum will be deposited to PubMed and Crossref.
  • The publisher will correct the paper and upload it to replace the current version. A note will appear within the corrected paper, informing the reader of the change that has been made and linking to the Erratum. All deposited versions (PubMed, CrossRef) will be replaced with the corrected paper. This process is in accordance with best practices for scientific publication.

After the changes have been implemented or if there are other updates, the information will be added to this Post-Publication Notes section.

Update on 20 December 2024

This matter was resolved on 20 December 2024.

The publisher published an
Erratum.

Graffius published new
article.

black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

scott_m_graffius_-_blog_spacer_-_v23111107_-_x---rev-24101207---copyright---lwres

Copyright


Copyright © Scott M. Graffius. All rights reserved.

Content on this site—including text, images, videos, and data—may not be used for training or input into any artificial intelligence, machine learning, or automatized learning systems, or published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without the express written permission of Scott M. Graffius.


black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

The short link for this article is
https://bit.ly/aans-jns


custom - back to main page of blog


Reporting Errors in a Publication: A Case Study on ‘Frontiers in Public Health’

BY SCOTT M. GRAFFIUS | ScottGraffius.com

reporting-errors-in-frontiers-in-public-health-publication---v2-lwres



Any updates after this article is published will appear in the Post-Publication Notes section at the end of the article.

black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

Introduction

Errors in published works can unleash a cascade of profound effects: they corrupt the well of knowledge, deceive those seeking truth, and shatter the foundation of credibility. As explored in
the widely read article on reporting errors, taking action to address such issues plays a pivotal role in ensuring the accuracy and integrity of knowledge.

But what happens when errors go unaddressed, even after being reported with detailed evidence? This article presents a case study from Graffius’ own experience, where a publication in
Frontiers in Public Health mischaracterized his research on the lifespan (half-life) of social media posts (2024 edition) and incorrectly cited his work. Despite reporting these issues to the lead author and publisher, the response—or lack thereof in this case—reveals the challenges and persistence required to uphold research integrity. Through this case study, this article illustrates the error reporting process, the importance of follow-through, and the lessons learned.

Graffius' 'Lifespan (Half-Life) of Social Media Posts' Research

When content is published on social media platforms, relevance and engagement have a limited lifespan. Most posts receive half of their total engagement (such as likes, shares, and comments) relatively soon, with the remainder spread out over a comparatively longer period. Said differently, plotting engagement against time typically reveals a distribution where the peak engagement occurs early, with a long tail of diminishing interaction, resembling a positively skewed unimodal distribution.

Given the above, an advantageous, objective metric for social media posts is half-life. It’s the time it takes for a post to receive half of its total engagement. Data can help inform strategic and tactical decisions, such as the frequency and scheduling of posts.

In 2018, Scott M. Graffius first published data on the average half-life of posts based on a large dataset comprised of multiple sources. Algorithms and other factors on platforms change over time. For that reason, Graffius periodically updates his 'Lifespan (Half-Life) of Social Media Posts' research. His work has captured the attention of, and is used by, a diverse global audience of businesses, professional associations, government agencies, universities, and others.

Errors in Frontiers in Public Health

A paper published in
Frontiers in Public Health, titled 'Public perceptions of digital mental health awareness campaign in the Arab Gulf states: a qualitative thematic analysis,' inaccurately portrayed findings from the 'Lifespan (Half-Life) of Social Media Posts' research. The Frontiers authors wrongly claimed that, "the lifespan of social media posts on most platforms is, at most, 9 days," conflating 'lifespan' with 'half-life.' Their error misrepresented the research’s conclusions. Furthermore, the Frontiers paper mis-referenced Graffius’ work, citing an incorrect title and omitting the DOI, undermining the accuracy of the scholarship.

Limited excerpts from the problematic
Frontiers in Public Health paper follow.

reporting-errors-in-frontiers-in-public-health-publication---excerpts-1-lwres

Due to its errors, the
Frontiers paper misleads readers, posing a risk of misinformation that could negatively impact future research or the improper application of its findings.

Action Taken: Reporting and Following Up on the Errors

Following Graffius' own recommendation on what to do when discovering errors (available at
https://scottgraffius.com/blog/files/error-reporting.html), he took action. On 18 December 2024, Graffius sent an email to the lead author, Noura Alomair, and included the editorial and publishing team at Frontiers in Public Health. The email delineated the factual error and the citation error, and it provided specific corrections for both. Excerpts from Graffius' email are shown in blue font.

1. Factual error.

The data collection section on page 03 includes this: "The lifespan of social media posts on most platforms is, at most, 9 days (19)."

However, the metric is half-life. I defined it in my research (which you cited): "The lifespan of posts is of interest, and a helpful metric is half-life. It’s the amount of time it takes for a post to receive half of its total engagement (such as likes, shares, and comments)."

Additional information — for background and context only:

  • When content is published online, relevance and engagement have a limited lifespan. Engagement is typically not distributed as a normal bell curve. Rather, it’s generally a unimodal distribution-based, positively skewed curve.
  • Here’s a description of the prototypical distribution of data (engagement): On average, most posts receive half of their total engagement relatively soon, with the remainder spread out over a comparatively long(er) period.
  • For those reasons, an advantageous respective objective metric for posts on social media platforms is half-life. It’s the time it takes for a post to receive half of its total engagement (such as likes, shares, and comments).
  • Built on a large dataset from multiple sources, Graffius’ research reveals the average lifespan (half-life) for posts on different social media platforms.
  • Note: Findings from others — including anecdotal experience from select posts or otherwise the experience of one person, one organization, or a limited dataset — may vary from the average half-life data in Graffius’ research.

Accordingly, I suggest that this:

"The lifespan of social media posts on most platforms is, at most, 9 days (19)."

is corrected to this (or similar):

"Posts on top social media platforms typically receive half of their total engagement (such as likes, shares, and comments) quickly, ranging from seconds to under nine days. After that half-life point, posts start to get buried in the news feed."

2. Citation error.

Except for my work, items in the references section reflect the following template/example: "Braun V, Clarke V. Reflecting on reflexive thematic analysis. Qual Res Sport, Exerc Health. (2019) 11:589– 97. doi: 10.1080/2159676X.2019.1628806". The reference for my work is shown as: "GRAFFIUS SM. Half-life for posts on different social media platforms. (2024)." My last name is in all caps, which is not consistent with other entries. Additionally, the title is wrong, and the DOI (or, alternatively, link) is missing.

I suggest that it is corrected to this:

"Graffius SM. Lifespan (half-life) of social media posts: update for 2024. (2024). doi: 10.13140/RG.2.2.21043.60965."

Except for an auto-reply from the publisher—which promised communication "within 5 business days"—there was no response to Graffius' report of the errors. As of 20 March 2025 (the date of this article), there have been
92 days of radio silence. That's deeply concerning.

Consistent with the persistence advocated for in Graffius' own error-reporting guide, he sent
a follow-up email on 20 March 2025, reiterating the errors and emphasizing the importance of research integrity. He wrote, "I imagine that, like me, you value the integrity of the academic record and would want to correct these errors to ensure the accuracy and reliability of the published work." This case study—inclusive of finding and reporting errors, getting radio silence, and more—underscores challenges of ensuring accountability in publishing.

Conclusion

As demonstrated by their action or inaction, some authors, editors, and publishers appreciate finding out about errors so that they can correct them, while others do not. The error reporting experience with
Frontiers in Public Health was frustrating due to inaction from both the lead author and the publishing team. Despite providing detailed evidence and following up after 92 days of silence, Graffius has yet to receive a response. This case underscores the persistence sometimes required to uphold integrity. It also highlights the importance of taking action: while the ideal response to an error report is prompt acknowledgment and correction, the reality can be radio silence—necessitating further effort.

Whether it's enhancing the experience for future readers or upholding the accuracy and integrity of scientific works, vigilance in reporting errors plays a pivotal role.

If there is an update on this case, it will appear in the Post-Publication Notes section which appears at the end of the article.

Read on for:

  • About Frontiers in Public Health,
  • About Graffius' 'Lifespan (Half-Life) of Social Media Posts' Research,
  • About Scott M. Graffius,
  • How to Cite This Article,
  • Post-Publication Notes,
  • and more.

black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

About Frontiers in Public Health

Frontiers in Public Health is a peer-reviewed, open-access journal that publishes research spanning multiple aspects of public health. Launched in 2013 by Frontiers Media, it covers topics such as health policy, epidemiology, environmental health, digital public health, and more. The journal is structured into specialty sections, including Public Mental Health, Health Economics, Aging and Public Health, and more. By fostering interdisciplinary collaboration and focused on disseminating high-quality research, Frontiers in Public Health plays a vital role in shaping public health policies and interventions worldwide.

black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

About Graffius' 'Lifespan (Half-Life) of Social Media Posts' Research

Scientists, researchers, journalists, academics, YouTubers, podcasters, SEO experts, analysts, businesses, and others around with world feature and use Scott M. Graffius' 'Lifespan (Half-Life) of Social Media Posts' research. The current (2025) edition is available here.

black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

About Scott M. Graffius

scott_m_graffius_-_blue_-_1000x1000_-lwres

Scott M. Graffius sparks breakthroughs in AI, agile, and project management/PMO leadership as a globally recognized practitioner, researcher, thought leader, award-winning author, and international public speaker.

Graffius has generated more than USD $1.9 billion in business value for organizations served, including Fortune 500 companies. Businesses and industries range from technology (including R&D and AI) to entertainment, financial services, and healthcare, government, social media, and more.

Graffius leads the professional services firm Exceptional PPM and PMO Solutions, along with its subsidiary Exceptional Agility. These consultancies offer strategic and tactical advisory, training, embedded talent, and consulting services to public, private, and government sectors. They help organizations enhance their capabilities and results in agile, project management, program management, portfolio management, and PMO leadership, supporting innovation and driving competitive advantage. The consultancies confidently back services with a Delighted Client Guarantee™. Graffius is a former vice president of project management with a publicly traded provider of diverse consumer products and services over the Internet. Before that, he ran and supervised the delivery of projects and programs in public and private organizations with businesses ranging from e-commerce to advanced technology products and services, retail, manufacturing, entertainment, and more. He has experience with consumer, business, reseller, government, and international markets.

He is the author of two award-winning books.
Organizations around the world invite Graffius to speak on tech (including AI), agile, project management, program management, portfolio management, and PMO leadership. He has developed and delivered unique and compelling talks and workshops. To date, Graffius has delivered 91 sessions across 25 countries. Select examples of events include Agile Trends Gov, BSides (Newcastle Upon Tyne), Conf42 Quantum Computing, DevDays Europe, DevOps Institute, DevOpsDays (Geneva), Frug’Agile, IEEE, Microsoft, Scottish Summit, Scrum Alliance RSG (Nepal), Techstars, and W Love Games International Video Game Development Conference (Helsinki), and more. With an average rating of 4.81 (on a scale of 1-5), sessions are highly valued.

Prominent businesses, professional associations, government agencies, and universities have featured Graffius and his work including content from his books, talks, workshops, and more. Select examples include:
  • Adobe,
  • American Management Association,
  • Amsterdam Public Health Research Institute,
  • Bayer,
  • BMC Software,
  • Boston University,
  • Broadcom,
  • Cisco,
  • Coburg University of Applied Sciences and Arts Germany,
  • Computer Weekly,
  • Constructor University Germany,
  • Data Governance Success,
  • Deimos Aerospace,
  • DevOps Institute,
  • EU's European Commission,
  • Ford Motor Company,
  • GoDaddy,
  • Harvard Medical School,
  • Hasso Plattner Institute Germany,
  • IEEE,
  • Innovation Project Management,
  • Johns Hopkins University,
  • Journal of Neurosurgery,
  • Lam Research (Semiconductors),
  • Leadership Worthy,
  • Life Sciences Trainers and Educators Network,
  • London South Bank University,
  • Microsoft,
  • NASSCOM,
  • National Academy of Sciences,
  • New Zealand Government,
  • Oracle,
  • Pinterest Inc.,
  • Project Management Institute,
  • SANS Institute,
  • SBG Neumark Germany,
  • Singapore Institute of Technology,
  • Torrens University Australia,
  • TBS Switzerland,
  • Tufts University,
  • UC San Diego,
  • UK Sports Institute,
  • University of Galway Ireland,
  • US Department of Energy,
  • US National Park Service,
  • US Tennis Association,
  • Veleuฤilište u Rijeci Croatia,
  • Verizon,
  • Virginia Tech,
  • Warsaw University of Technology,
  • Wrike,
  • Yale University,
  • and many others.

Graffius has been actively involved with the Project Management Institute (PMI) in the development of professional standards. He was a member of the team which produced the
Practice Standard for Work Breakdown Structures—Second Edition. Graffius was a contributor and reviewer of A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge—Sixth Edition, The Standard for Program Management—Fourth Edition, and The Practice Standard for Project Estimating—Second Edition. He was also a subject matter expert reviewer of content for the PMI’s Congress. Beyond the PMI, Graffius also served as a member of the review team for two of the Scrum Alliance’s Global Scrum Gatherings.

Graffius has a bachelor’s degree in psychology with a focus in Human Factors. He holds eight professional certifications:

  • Certified SAFe 6 Agilist (SA),
  • Certified Scrum Professional - ScrumMaster (CSP-SM),
  • Certified Scrum Professional - Product Owner (CSP-PO),
  • Certified ScrumMaster (CSM),
  • Certified Scrum Product Owner (CSPO),
  • Project Management Professional (PMP),
  • Lean Six Sigma Green Belt (LSSGB), and
  • IT Service Management Foundation (ITIL).

He is an active member of the Scrum Alliance, the Project Management Institute (PMI), and the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE).

He divides his time between Los Angeles and Paris, France.

Thought Leader | Public Speaker | Agile Scrum Book | Agile Transformation Book | Blog | Photo | X | LinkedIn | Email

black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

pinterest-inc-references-scott-m-graffius0027-research---v1-3---lwres

cisco-features-scott-m.-graffius0027-0027phases-of-team-development0027-work---rectange---lwres

ieee-xplore-publication-featured-scott-m-graffius-phases-of-team-development-work---rev-sept-19-2024---hires

uc-san-diego-features-scott-m-graffius-intellectual-property-on-teamwork---geisel---creative-24101007---lwres

johns-hopkins-university-features-work-of-scott-m-graffius---v24080107---tw---lwres

semiconductor-manufacturing-firm-lam-research-features-scott-m-graffius2019-2018phases-of-team-development2019-intellectual-property---tw-sz-format---lwres

bayer-licensed-ip-of-agile-expert-scott-m-graffius---agilescrumguide_com---lwres

award-winning-agile-scrum-book-by-scott-m-graffius-v24122207lwres

scott_m_graffius_agile_transformation_sq_lr_1000x1000

25-unforgettable-gifts-from-usd-149-to-2640000---scottgraffius-com---lwres

scottgraffius-youtube---v25032307-lwres

black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

Feature-focused

Sign up for Miro—it's free!

(Want more features? You can always upgrade to a paid plan.)

black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

scott_m_graffius_-_blog_spacer_-_v23111107_-_cite

How to Cite This Article


Graffius, Scott M. (2025, March 20).
Reporting Errors in 'Frontiers in Public Health': A Case Study. Available at: https://scottgraffius.com/blog/files/reporting-errors-in-frontiers-of-public-health-publication.html.

black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

scott_m_graffius_-_blog_spacer_-_v23111107_-_x---rev-24101207---doi----lwres

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)


DOI: (coming soon)


black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

scott_m_graffius_-_blog_spacer_-_v23111107_-_x---rev-24101207---content-acknowledgements---lwres

Content Acknowledgements

This article includes brief excerpts from Frontiers in Public Health ('Public perceptions of digital mental health awareness campaign in the Arab Gulf states: a qualitative thematic analysis' by Noura Alomair, Ghadah Alkhaldi, Norah M. Alsadhan, Rawan Alkasabi, and Samah Alageel), attributed and used under fair use for news reporting and analysis.

Frontiers in Public Health is the property of Frontiers Media S.A.

Graffius’ Lifespan (Half-Life) of Social Media Posts' is copyright © Scott M. Graffius. All rights reserved.

black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

spacer-post-publication-notes-1000pxw

Post-Publication Notes

If there's an update after this article is published, the information will appear here.

Update on 24 March 2025

On 24 March 2025, Frontiers (the publisher) sent an email to Graffius. Here’s an excerpt:

"This is to let you know that the corresponding author has submitted a corrigendum for the article based on your comments. Our editorial team will review the corrigendum."

Update on 24 March 2025

On 24 March 2025, Graffius replied to Frontiers’ email. Here’s an excerpt:

"Please:

1. Inform me know when you’re scheduled to implement the corrections (or an estimated date), and
2. Update me after you’ve implemented the corrections."

Update on 25 March 2025

On 25 March 2025, Frontiers (the publisher) sent an email to Graffius. Here’s an excerpt from it:

"If the corrigendum is accepted, I will send you the link to the online page. There will also be a visible link to the Corrigendum on the original article, as soon as the article is accepted. Once an article is accepted, they are published within 3 weeks on average. Please note that once an article is updated, it can take longer for the update to be reflected in certain repositories, depending on the repository."

Update on 28 March 2025

The most recent update from the publisher was on 25 March 2025. It's noted above.

For context, Graffius reported the errors on 18 December 2024. As of today, that was
100 days ago, and the errors have not yet been resolved.

Update on 14 May 2025

As a recap, Graffius reported the errors on 18 December 2024. On 14 May 2025 — 147 days later — the errors were resolved. The correction notice ("Corrigendum: Public perceptions of digital mental health awareness campaign in the Arab Gulf states: a qualitative thematic analysis") is at https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/public-health/articles/10.3389/fpubh.2025.1597875/full. It reports this:

"A Corrigendum on

Public perceptions of digital mental health awareness campaign in the Arab Gulf states: a qualitative thematic analysis

by Alomair, N., Alkhaldi, G., Alsadhan, N. M., Alkasabi, R., and Alageel, S. (2024). Front. Public Health. 12:1477315. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2024.1477315

In the published article, the reference for (19) was incorrectly written as “GRAFFIUS SM. Half-life for posts on different social media platforms”. It should be:

19. Graffius SM. Lifespan (half-life) of social media posts: update for 2024. (2024). doi: 10.13140/RG.2.2.21043.60965

The published article erroneously paraphrased the lifespan of social media posts.

A correction has been made to Methods, Data collection. This sentence previously stated:

"The lifespan of social media posts on most platforms is, at most, 9 days."

The corrected sentence appears below:

"Posts on top social media platforms typically receive half of their total engagement (such as likes, shares, and comments) quickly, ranging from seconds to under nine days. After that half-life point, posts start to get buried in the news feed."

The authors apologize for this error and state that this does not change the scientific conclusions of the article in any way. The original article has been updated."


The corrected journal paper is at
https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/public-health/articles/10.3389/fpubh.2024.1477315/full.

black_spacer_lr_sq_v3

scott_m_graffius_-_blog_spacer_-_v23111107_-_x---rev-24101207---copyright---lwres

Copyright

Copyright © Scott M. Graffius. All rights reserved.

Content on this site—including text, images, videos, and data—may not be used for training or input into any artificial intelligence, machine learning, or automatized learning systems, or published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without the express written permission of Scott M. Graffius.






custom - back to main page of blog





A Critical Analysis of Sage Publications' Author Page for Bruce W. Tuckman

BY SCOTT M. GRAFFIUS | ScottGraffius.com



critical-analysis-of-sage-publications-author-page-for-bruce-w-tuckman---vis-lwres


Recommended Citation

Graffius, S. M. (2026, November 16).
A Critical Analysis of Sage Publications' Author Page for Bruce W. Tuckman. ScottGraffius.com. https://scottgraffius.com/blog/files/critical-analysis-of-sage-publications-author-page-for-bruce-w-tuckman.html




About This Article

Source information and links for materials cited are provided in the References section.




Introduction



Sage Publications maintains an author profile for Bruce Wayne Tuckman (1938–2016) on its website. The entry describes his academic career, publications, and contributions to educational research. It credits him with developing the group development model widely known as Tuckman’s Stages of Group Development.

There is a problem. The biography omits important parts of that history, and its shortcomings are especially hard to excuse given Sage Publications’ history.

The entry refers to the four stages of forming, storming, norming, and performing. It says nothing about adjourning, the fifth stage added in 1977. Nor does it mention Mary Ann C. Jensen, Tuckman’s coauthor on the paper that introduced that addition. The biography also uses an imprecise date for the original work and provides no references to either foundational publication.

The original publications and their bibliographic records are readily identifiable, their publication dates and authorship are unambiguous, and the 1977 paper explicitly identifies the addition of adjourning.

Sage Publications’ own publishing portfolio makes the problems striking. An examination of the original research and the journal’s publishing history reveals serious deficiencies.

Note

  • Metadata for Sage Publications' author page for Bruce Wayne Tuckman indicates it was created on 4 September 2025 and last modified on 31 October 2026.
  • This critical analysis article is based on the version of Sage Publications’ author page available on 16 November 2026, the date of this article’s publication.
  • If Sage Publications subsequently revises the page, those changes will postdate this analysis. However, such revisions will not alter the content examined or the basis for the observations and conclusions presented here.






5 Key Issues



1. Imprecise Dating of the Original Work

Sage Publications writes:

“In the 1960s, he developed Tuckman’s Stages of Group Development…”

The date of the original publication is 1965. Tuckman’s paper, “Developmental Sequence in Small Groups,” appeared in
Psychological Bulletin, 63(6), 384–399.

Why use a decade when the exact year is known and readily verifiable?

The distinction matters because the model did not emerge as a single, finished contribution. Tuckman published the original four-stage formulation in 1965. Twelve years later, in 1977, he and Mary Ann C. Jensen revisited the research and added a fifth stage.

Sage Publications’ wording blurs that chronology. It is a small editorial decision with a larger consequence: readers are given no indication that the model developed through two distinct publications.

An academic publisher should get such basic historical details right. The appropriate date is 1965, not the vague reference to the 1960s.

2. The Missing Fifth Stage

Sage Publications identifies the stages as:

“forming, storming, norming, and performing”

The subsequent 1977 paper added a fifth stage: adjourning.

The original four-stage model appeared in Tuckman’s 1965 paper. In 1977, Tuckman and Jensen published “Stages of Small-Group Development Revisited.” Their paper reviewed subsequent research and extended the original model.

The abstract leaves no room for doubt:

“Following a review of these studies, a fifth stage, ‘adjourning,’ was added…”

That is the primary source speaking for itself.

Sage Publications’ biography omits the fifth stage entirely. Readers unfamiliar with the research could reasonably come away believing that the four-stage formulation is the complete model. It is not.

Adjourning is a meaningful part of the model. It addresses the conclusion of a group’s work and the process of disbanding. Its omission leaves out an important aspect of group development, particularly relevant to temporary teams, project teams, and other groups formed to accomplish a defined purpose.

The problem is not that Sage Publications chose a simplified explanation for a general audience. A concise biography could easily have acknowledged both versions. Instead, it presents an incomplete account without explaining that a subsequent publication expanded the model.

For a publisher responsible for disseminating scholarly work, that is a substantial editorial failure.

3. Mary Ann C. Jensen’s Co-authorship Is Not Acknowledged

There is another omission, and this one concerns authorship.

Bruce W. Tuckman and Mary Ann C. Jensen jointly wrote the 1977 paper that introduced adjourning:

Tuckman, B. W., & Jensen, M. A. C. (1977). Stages of small-group development revisited.
Group & Organization Studies, 2(4), 419–427.

Sage Publications’ biography does not mention the paper. It does not mention Jensen. The result is an account that attributes the development of the model exclusively to Tuckman, without acknowledging the coauthored work that expanded it.

Jensen was a named coauthor of the publication that introduced the fifth stage. That contribution belongs in any account of the model.

Authorship attribution is not a peripheral concern in academic publishing. It is fundamental. Researchers depend on accurate records of who contributed to published work, and publishers have a responsibility to preserve that record.

Sage Publications’ omission does neither.

Whatever the editorial process behind the biography, the published result fails to recognize Jensen’s contribution. That should be corrected.

4. Sage Publications’ Own Publishing History Makes the Omission Particularly Damaging

This is where the problem becomes especially difficult Sage to explain.

Consider the publishing histories of the two foundational papers.

The 1965 paper

Tuckman’s “Developmental Sequence in Small Groups” was published in
Psychological Bulletin, 63(6), 384–399, in 1965.

The publisher was, and remains, the American Psychological Association (APA).

The 1977 paper

Tuckman and Jensen’s “Stages of Small-Group Development Revisited” appeared in
Group & Organization Studies, 2(4), 419–427, in 1977.

The publisher at that time was University Associates. The publication also carried a copyright notice identifying International Authors, B.V.

The journal’s publishing history subsequently changed. Sage Publications became its publisher in 1981. In 1991, the journal changed its name from “Group & Organization Studies” to “Group & Organization Management.”

Sage Publications’ own announcement concerning its founder, Sara Miller McCune, and the transfer of control to the Sage SMM Trust documents the organization’s history. Its publishing connection to the journal is also reflected in the journal’s historical records.

The significance of this publishing history is considerable: Sage Publications now publishes the journal in which Tuckman and Jensen published the paper that introduced adjourning.

Yet Sage Publications’ own biography of Tuckman fails to mention that paper, the fifth stage, or Jensen.

This is more than an ordinary omission. The relevant publication sits within Sage Publications’ own publishing history. The original paper is not difficult to locate, and its title, authorship, date, and abstract are explicit. Sage Publications has a direct institutional connection to the journal in which it appeared.

One would expect that connection to make verification easier, not less likely.

The irony is remarkable. Sage Publications publishes the journal containing the primary source for the fifth stage, yet its own author biography presents the four-stage version without acknowledging the subsequent development.

That is a failure of editorial diligence.

5. What Does This Say About Sage Publications’ Editorial Standards?

The deficiencies are material.

The page uses an imprecise date for a well-documented publication. It omits a fifth stage explicitly introduced in a subsequent paper. It fails to acknowledge that paper’s coauthor. It does not distinguish the 1965 and 1977 contributions, and it provides no references to either foundational work.

All of those problems were avoidable.

The information needed to prepare an accurate biography is readily available in the original publications. The 1977 abstract even spells out the addition of adjourning. The journal’s publishing history is also documented. None of this requires an elaborate literature review or an unusual degree of specialist knowledge.

A publisher maintaining an author profile must verify the facts about that author’s most recognized contribution.

There is a difference between an abbreviated biography and an inaccurate one. Author profiles may not include every publication, achievement, or historical detail. Brevity is understandable. But leaving out a major development in the subject’s best-known model, while also failing to credit its coauthor, crosses the line from selectivity into material incompleteness.

As an academic publisher, Sage Publications’ conduct makes this matter especially consequential. Its website is a source that researchers, educators, students, and practitioners may consult when looking for reliable information.

The current entry falls short of the accuracy and completeness expected of an academic publisher.





Conclusion



Sage Publications should correct its page on Tuckman. It should identify 1965 as the year of Tuckman’s original four-stage formulation, acknowledge the 1977 paper by Tuckman and Jensen, include adjourning as the fifth stage, and (as an academic publisher) provide full citations for both papers.

The publishing history makes the omission especially troubling. Sage later became the publisher of the journal in which the 1977 paper appeared, yet its own biography of Tuckman overlooks that paper’s central contribution. The error concerns work published within Sage’s own portfolio.

Sage is an academic publisher whose materials reach researchers, educators, students, practitioners, and organizations that reasonably treat its content as reliable. That trust carries a responsibility for factual accuracy and scholarly attribution. And the responsibility extends to publisher-maintained biographies as well as peer-reviewed research. An author profile may be concise, but it must not give readers an inaccurate account of the subject’s work.

For an organization that trades on scholarly credibility, Sage Publications' publishing materially misleading information is an unacceptable failure.





Unlock Your Organization's Potential



scott-m-graffius-2026-profile-vCj3L8b-11-lwres

Scott M. Graffius helps organizations unlock breakthrough performance and generate billions in business value ($3.1 billion to date) through leadership in AI, Agile, teamwork tradecraft, and project, program, portfolio, and enterprise PMO management.

Graffius and his work on Agile, AI, teamwork tradecraft, and more are used and cited by businesses, professional associations, government agencies, universities, and publications around the world. Select examples include Adobe, Amsterdam Public Health Research Institute, The ATACC Group (TAG), Bayer, BCG, Boston University, École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, Federal Reserve Bank of New York, Gartner, Government of Canada, Harvard Medical School, IEEE,
Innovation Project Management, Johns Hopkins University, Journal of Marketing, Journal of Neurosurgery, Life Sciences Trainers & Educators Network (LTEN), Microsoft, National Academy of Sciences, Oracle, Pinterest, Project Management Institute, Royal Australasian College of Physicians (RACP), UC San Diego, U.S. Tennis Association, Verizon, and Yale University.

Put Graffius' experience and expertise to work for your organization.
For speaking engagements, use the request form. For other inquiries, email him.





References



Khorshidi, M. S., Merigó, J. M., et al. (2026). 50th anniversary of Group & Organization Management: A bibliometric retrospective.
Group & Organization Management. https://doi.org/10.1177/10596011261433510

Sage Publications. (n.d.). Bruce Wayne Tuckman (deceased).
https://www.sagepub.com/explore-our-content/authors/bruce-w-tuckman-deceased-666202

Sage Publications. (2021, December 7). SAGE Publishing founder Sara Miller McCune passes control of SAGE to the SAGE SMM Trust.
https://www.sagepub.com/explore-our-content/press-office/press-releases/2021/12/07/sage-publishing-founder-sara-miller-mccune-passes-control-of-sage-to-the-sage-smm-trust

Tuckman, B. W. (1965). Developmental sequence in small groups.
Psychological Bulletin, 63(6), 384–399. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0022100

Tuckman, B. W., & Jensen, M. A. C. (1977). Stages of small-group development revisited.
Group & Organization Studies, 2(4), 419–427. https://doi.org/10.1177/105960117700200404





About This Critical Analysis



This article examines Sage Publications’ biographical entry for Bruce W. Tuckman, focusing on its historical accuracy, completeness, scholarly attribution, and treatment of the original research.

The analysis draws primarily on the 1965 and 1977 publications and the documented publishing history of the journals in which they appeared.





About Scott M. Graffius



scott_m_graffius_-_blue_-_1000x1000_-lwres

Scott M. Graffius is a technology leader, researcher, award-winning author, practitioner, consultant, thought leader, and international public speaker specializing in AI, Agile, project/program/portfolio management (PPPM), PMO leadership, and teamwork tradecraft. His work explores the intersection of human ingenuity and emerging technology, with a strong practitioner voice grounded in research, experimentation, and experience. His focus includes innovation, organizational performance, and the evolving practice of teamwork, including the "exotic team dynamics" that emerge when people collaborate with advanced artificial intelligence (agentic, autonomous, or autopoietic AI). Graffius has delivered more than $3.1 billion in business value for Fortune 500 companies and other organizations spanning technology, entertainment and media, financial services, healthcare, government, and other industries.

Businesses, professional associations, government agencies, universities, publications, and media outlets use Graffius and his work. Examples include Adobe, Bayer, Boston University, Federal Reserve Bank of New York, Ford, Gartner, Harvard Medical School, IEEE, Innovation Project Management, Johns Hopkins University, Microsoft, MSN, National Academy of Sciences, Oracle, Pinterest Inc., Project Management Institute, UC San Diego, Verizon, Yale University, and others.

The following sections highlight his experience, leadership, contributions, research, and enduring influence across industries and institutions worldwide.

Experience

Graffius heads the professional services firm Exceptional PPM and PMO Solutions, along with its subsidiary Exceptional Agility. These consultancies offer strategic and tactical advisory, training, embedded expertise, and consulting services to the public, private, and government sectors. They help organizations enhance their capabilities and results in agile, project management, program management, portfolio management, and enterprise PMO leadership, supporting innovation and driving competitive advantage. The consultancies confidently back services with a Delighted Client Guarantee™.

Graffius is a former VP of project management with a publicly traded provider of diverse consumer products and services over the Internet. Before that, he ran and supervised the delivery of projects and programs in public and private organizations with businesses ranging from e-commerce to advanced technology products and services, retail, manufacturing, entertainment and media, and more.

He has experience with consumer, business, reseller, government, and international markets.

Additional information is on
LinkedIn.

Award-Winning Author

Graffius has authored three books.

Graffius' first book, Agile Scrum: Your Quick Start Guide with Step-by-Step Instructions, earned 17 awards. It provides a practical, step-by-step guide to Scrum, enabling teams to deliver products in short cycles with rapid adaptation, fast time-to-market, and continuous improvement—which supports innovation and drives competitive advantage.

  • Paperback ISBN-13: 9781533370242
  • Kindle ASIN: B01FZ0JIIY

Additional information on
Agile Scrum: Your Quick Start Guide with Step-by-Step Instructions is here.

ASG - Award Winning Agile Scrum Book by Scott M Graffius - v260427 - lwres

His second book,
Agile Transformation: A Brief Story of How an Entertainment Company Developed New Capabilities and Unlocked Business Agility to Thrive in an Era of Rapid Change, was named one of the best Scrum books of all time by BookAuthority. It tells the compelling story of an entertainment company's agile transformation—offering lessons that apply across industries.

  • Paperback ISBN-13: 9781072447962
  • Kindle ASIN: B07R9LJLPJ

Additional information on
Agile Transformation: A Brief Story of How an Entertainment Company Developed New Capabilities and Unlocked Business Agility to Thrive in an Era of Rapid Change is here.

scott_m_graffius_agile_transformation_sq_lr_1000x1000

Agile Protocol: The Transformation Ultimatum, is his third book—and his first work of fiction.

It's a fast-paced satirical story by that dismantles corporate Agile cosplay and other forms of "fake Agile" while delivering practical insights, actionable guidance, and proven practices for real-world Agile transformation success.

Packed with humor, quirky characters, sharp commentary on corporate culture and workplace absurdities, and actionable tips, it’s a must-read for Scrum Masters, Product Owners, Agile Coaches, Agile Project Managers, and other professionals interested in Agile project management and enterprise agility.

  • Kindle ASIN: B0F2SJ83WT
  • Audible ASIN: B0DJG163R5

Additional information on
Agile Protocol: The Transformation Ultimatum is here.

Agile Protocol - sq - v260427-top9G-IG lwres

International Public Speaker

Organizations worldwide engage Graffius to present on technology (including AI), Agile, project management, program management, portfolio management, and enterprise PMO leadership. He crafts and delivers unique and compelling talks and workshops.

Graffius has conducted 99 sessions across 25 countries. Select examples of events include Agile Trends Gov, BSides (Newcastle Upon Tyne), Conf42 Quantum Computing, DevDays Europe, DevOps Institute, DevOpsDays (Geneva), Frug’Agile, IEEE, Microsoft, Scottish Summit, Scrum Alliance RSG (Nepal), Techstars, and W Love Games International Video Game Development Conference (Helsinki), Future of Work and Advanced AI (Paris, France), and more.

With an average rating of 4.82 (on a scale of 1-5), sessions are highly valued.

The request form is
here.

Thought Leadership and Influence

Prominent businesses, professional associations, government agencies, and universities have showcased Graffius and his contributions—spanning his books, talks, workshops, and beyond. Select examples include:

  • Adobe,
  • American Management Association,
  • Amsterdam Public Health Research Institute,
  • Bayer,
  • BCG,
  • BMC Software,
  • Boston Consulting Group (BCG),
  • Boston University,
  • Broadcom,
  • Cisco,
  • Coburg University of Applied Sciences and Arts - Germany,
  • Computer Weekly,
  • Constructor University - Germany,
  • Data Governance Success,
  • Deimos Aerospace,
  • DevOps Institute,
  • Dropbox,
  • EU's European Commission,
  • Federal Reserve Bank of New York,
  • Ford Motor Company,
  • Gartner,
  • GoDaddy,
  • Harvard Medical School,
  • Hasso Plattner Institute - Germany,
  • IEEE,
  • Innovation Project Management,
  • Johns Hopkins University,
  • Journal of Marketing,
  • Journal of Neurosurgery,
  • Lam Research (Semiconductors),
  • Leadership Worthy,
  • Life Sciences Trainers and Educators Network,
  • London South Bank University,
  • Microsoft,
  • MSN,
  • NASSCOM,
  • National Academy of Sciences,
  • New Zealand Government,
  • Ohio State University,
  • Oracle,
  • Pinterest Inc.,
  • Project Management Institute,
  • Mary Raum (Professor of National Security Affairs, United States Naval War College),
  • Round Square Global Educational Network,
  • Royal Australasian College of Physicians (RACP),
  • SANS Institute,
  • SBG Neumark - Germany,
  • Singapore Institute of Technology,
  • Torrens University - Australia,
  • TBS Switzerland,
  • Tufts University,
  • UC San Diego,
  • UK Sports Institute,
  • University of Galway - Ireland,
  • US Department of Energy,
  • US National Park Service,
  • US Soccer,
  • US Tennis Association,
  • Verizon,
  • Wrike,
  • Yale University,
  • and many others.

Graffius has played a key role in the Project Management Institute (PMI) in developing professional standards. He was a member of multiple teams that authored, reviewed, and produced:


He was also a subject matter expert reviewer of content for the PMI’s Congress. Beyond the PMI, Graffius also served as a member of the review team for two of the Scrum Alliance’s Global Scrum Gatherings.

Authority on Teamwork Tradecraft

Scott-M-Graffius-Phases-Of-Team-Development-2026-Update-v26010307G2-jpg-lwres

Graffius is a renowned and highly-cited authority on teamwork tradecraft. Informed by the research of Bruce W. Tuckman and Mary Ann C. Jensen, over 150 subsequent studies, and Graffius' first-hand professional experience with, and analysis of, team leadership and performance, Graffius created his "Phases of Team Development" intellectual property as a unique perspective and visual conveying the five phases of team development.

First introduced in 2008 and periodically updated, his work provides a diagnostic and strategic guide for navigating team dynamics. It provides actionable insights for leaders across industries to develop high-performance teams.

nsdm-publication-by-nsa-raum-referenced-work-by-graffius-on-team-development---2026-refresh-IG-lwres

Its adoption by esteemed organizations—such as Yale University, IEEE, Cisco, Microsoft, Ford, Oracle, Broadcom, the U.S. National Park Service, and the
Journal of Neurosurgery, among others—highlights its utility and value, solidifying its status as an indispensable resource for elevating team performance and driving organizational excellence.

In 2026, Graffius added human-AI teamwork—including the "
exotic team dynamics" which emerge when advanced AI collaborates as a teammate—to his "Phases of Team Development." The 2026 edition is here.

Expert on Temporal Dynamics on Social Media Platforms

scott-m-graffius-lifespan-halflife-of-social-media-posts-update-for-2026-summary-visual-v26012207-jpg-lwres

Graffius is also an authority on temporal dynamics on social media platforms. His "Lifespan (Half-Life) of Social Media Posts" research—first published in 2018 and updated annually—delivers a precise quantitative analysis of post longevity across digital platforms, utilizing advanced statistical techniques to determine mean half-life with precision. It establishes a solid empirical base, effectively highlighting the ephemeral nature of content within social media ecosystems.

Referenced and applied by leading entities—such as Fast Company, GoDaddy,
Journal of Hand Surgery (European Volume), Ministère de la Culture, Pinterest Inc., PNAS, and Telecommunications Policy, among others—his research exemplifies methodological rigor and sustained significance in the field of digital informatics.

The 2026 edition of Graffius "Lifespan (Half-Life) of Social Media Posts" research is here.

Education and Professional Certifications

Graffius has a bachelor’s degree in psychology with a focus in Human Factors. He holds eight professional certifications:

  • Certified SAFe 6 Agilist (SA),
  • Certified Scrum Professional - ScrumMaster (CSP-SM),
  • Certified Scrum Professional - Product Owner (CSP-PO),
  • Certified ScrumMaster (CSM),
  • Certified Scrum Product Owner (CSPO),
  • Project Management Professional (PMP),
  • Lean Six Sigma Green Belt (LSSGB), and
  • IT Service Management Foundation (ITIL).

He is an active member of the Scrum Alliance, the Project Management Institute (PMI), and the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE).

Advancing AI, Agile, and Project/PMO Management

Scott M. Graffius continues to advance the fields of AI, Agile, and project/program/portfolio management (PPPM), and PMO leadership. Businesses and other organizations leverage Graffius’ insights to drive their success.




Booking


Graffius has generated over $3.1 billion in business value for Fortune 500 companies and other organizations served. Put that track record to work for you. For speaking engagements, use the request form; for other inquiries, email him.




Connect with and follow Scott on LinkedIn, X, YouTube, Facebook, Bluesky, Mastodon, and ResearchGate.




scott-m-graffius-generated-over-3-point-1-billion-dollars---visual-hires-ig-lwres




pinterest-inc-references-scott-m-graffius0027-research---v1-3---lwres

cisco-features-scott-m.-graffius0027-0027phases-of-team-development0027-work---rectange---lwres

ieee-xplore-publication-featured-scott-m-graffius-phases-of-team-development-work---rev-sept-19-2024---hires

ucsd-featured-ip-of-scott-m-graffius---v25122907-giesel-lwres

johns-hopkins-university-features-work-of-scott-m-graffius---v24080107---tw---lwres

semiconductor-manufacturing-firm-lam-research-features-scott-m-graffius2019-2018phases-of-team-development2019-intellectual-property---tw-sz-format---lwres

bayer-licensed-ip-of-agile-expert-scott-m-graffius---agilescrumguide_com---lwres

ASG - Award Winning Agile Scrum Book by Scott M Graffius - v260427 - lwres

scott_m_graffius_agile_transformation_sq_lr_1000x1000

Agile Protocol - sq - v260427 lwres

gifts-that-inspire-joy-2026-2027-edition---visual-lwres

scottgraffius-youtube---v25032307-lwres




Feature-focused

Sign up for Miro—it's free!

(Want more features? You can always upgrade to a paid plan.)




scottgraffius-com-article-sections-v2026-more-lwres

List of Additional Articles



Read more.

Meta CTO Called the AI Reorganization “Atrocious” — What Went Wrong and the Lessons for Human-AI Teams

A Critical Analysis of "AI and Quantum Computers Will Be Frenemies"

A Supplement to Graffius' Phases of Team Development: Exploring the Original, Data-Based Curvature for the Performance Trajectory

Scott M. Graffius Speaking on Strategic Leadership at Silicon Valley Chapter of the Project Management Institute

AI Hallucinations, Deception, and Unauthorized Agency: The Spectrum of AI Trust Failures

A Critical Analysis of "The Social Cost of an AI Teammate: How an Artificial Teammate Reshapes Human-Human Communication in Small-Team Decision-Making"

Journal of Marketing Cites Scott M. Graffius' Research on the Half-Life of Social Media

The Evolution of Pair Programming and the Rise of Exotic Team Dynamics

Number 1 University in England for Student Satisfaction Features Scott M. Graffius' "Phases of Team Development"

Royal Australasian College of Physicians Licenses Scott M. Graffius' "Phases of Team Development" Intellectual Property on Teamwork Tradecraft

Exotic Team Dynamics: How Advanced AI Teammates Are Unlocking New Levels of Innovation, Performance, and Success

A Critical Analysis of "Platform-Specific Data Decay Patterns: A Comparative Study of Twitter, Reddit, and TikTok" and Its Reference to Research by Scott M. Graffius

Round Square Global Educational Network Features Scott M. Graffius’ Phases of Team Development

Meta's Muse Missed the Mark: Hollywood’s Win Against Big Tech on AI Consent and Likeness Rights

Scott M. Graffius Contributed to Seven Project Management Institute (PMI) Standards
Quantum Computing, Advanced AI Acceleration, and the Rise of Exotic Team Dynamics in Human-AI Teams

Ohio State University Course Features Scott M. Graffius' "Phases of Team Development"

Questions About Integrity at UNC Chapel Hill

Scrum Isn’t Just for Coding

Book on Generative and Agentic AI Cites Scott M. Graffius' Work on AI

IPA / ADAL Publication Plagiarized Another’s Copyrighted Work and Violated Intellectual Property Rights

UC Davis' Integrity Is Circling the Drain

L'avenir du Travail et de l'IA Avancée / Future of Work and Advanced AI

NCCI / UNC Chapel Hill Publication Features Scott M. Graffius' Work

Boston Consulting Group (BCG) Features Scott M. Graffius' Research on Social Media Content Half-Life

UC Davis Used Scott M. Graffius' "Phases of Team Development" Intellectual Property

Medical, Pharma, and Healthcare Organizations Are Using Scott M. Graffius' "Phases of Team Development"

Government of Ireland Report Features Research by Scott M. Graffius

Scott M. Graffius Contributed to The Standard for Artificial Intelligence in Portfolio, Program, and Project Management

AI Governance Initiative Cites Scott M. Graffius Research on AI Hallucinations

Scott M. Graffius Contributed to the Agile Practice Guide - Second Edition

Scott M. Graffius Generated Over $2.51 Billion in Business Value for Fortune 500 Companies and Other Organizations

Government of Canada Features Research by Scott M. Graffius

"Strategic Business Research" Journal Cites Work of Scott M. Graffius

IEEE Access Publication Features Scott M. Graffius’ Research on the Half-Life of Social Media

The Agile Coach: 2026 Edition

Scott M. Graffius’ Work Cited in International Peer-Reviewed Journal on Digital Transformation

Phases of Team Development in Elite Sport

A Critical Analysis of COVID-19 Treatment Search Trends and Media Coverage Study Citing Scott M. Graffius' Work

Human-AI Teamwork: Master the Exotic Team Dynamics That Emerge When Collaborating with Advanced AI -- Or Be Outplayed

"Agile Scrum" by Scott M. Graffius Now Featured on Grokipedia

UNSW Aerospace Engineering Course Features Scott M. Graffius' "Phases of Team Development"

Thinkers360 Honors Scott M. Graffius as a 2026 Top Agile Thought Leader

Agile's Journey Through the Decades: Update for 2026

BMC Software Features Content from Scott M. Graffius' Book

Peer-Reviewed Journal Cited Work of Scott M. Graffius
University of Waterloo Features Graffius' "Phases of Team Development" in Course Materials

Perplexity Standalone Article on AI Hallucinations Cites Research by Scott M. Graffius

Handling the Saboteur Within: Lessons from a 3-Letter Agency on Spotting and Stopping Intentional and Unintentional Sabotage

A Deep Dive Into the Typical Engagement Pattern for Social Media Posts

Most Valuable IT Certifications: Update for 2026

"Marketing in the Metaverse" Spotlights Scott M. Graffius’ Research on the Half-Life of Social Media

University of Greenwich Features Graffius' Phases of Team Development


10 Essential Agile Books: Curated Recommendations for Agile Professionals

Lifespan (Half-Life) of Social Media Posts: Update for 2026

Scott M. Graffius' Research on the Half-Life of Social Media was Cited in a Peer-Reviewed Study Published in Telecommunications Policy, a Leading Academic Journal

Are AI Hallucinations Getting Better or Worse? We Analyzed the Data

Scott M. Graffius' Phases of Team Development - Applied to Human Teams and Human-AI Teams: 2026 Update

Lessons from Yesterday’s Tomorrowland

Scott M. Graffius’ Update to His "Phases of Team Development” Coming Early 2026

A Data-Driven Analysis of the Evolution of Project Management: Tasks, Trends, and AI

Actionable Insights. Global Impact. Scott M. Graffius.

Beep Beep! Why Wile E. Coyote Is the Patron Saint of AI Failure

Social Media Half-Life Research Cited in Prestigious Peer-Reviewed Medical Journal

Navigating the Spectrum of Advanced AI – Agentic, Autonomous, and Autopoietic

Lessons from Unhinged AI in Fiction: What Rogue AIs in Sci-Fi Storytelling, Films, and TV Shows Reveal About Us

Scott M. Graffius Contributed to and Reviewed the PMBOK Guide, 8th Edition — the Global Standard for Project Management

UK Sports Institute Features Teamwork and Leadership Work of Scott M. Graffius

Definitions of Advanced AIs: Agentic, Autonomous, and Autopoietic

HAN University of Applied Sciences Features the Work of Scott M. Graffius

Gifts That Inspire Joy

Evergreen Echoes: How Pinterest Inc. and Pinterest Japan Spotlighted Scott M. Graffius’ Research on the Half-Life of Social Media Content

Scott M. Graffius’ Team Development Work Lights Up the University of Tasmania’s Curriculum

Taiwan’s Leading Outlet for Technology and Innovation Spotlights Graffius’ Research on Social Media Temporal Dynamics

Scott M. Graffius’ Insights on AI, Agile, Gaming, XR, and Defense Transformation Cited by MSN in Their Coverage of Innovation and Leadership in the Sector

Top Predictions of 2024, Tested in 2025

Government of Finland Agency Features Graffius' Phases of Team Development IP

Scott M. Graffius Premieres His New "Exotic Team Dynamics: Human-AI Collaboration" Talk at Corporate Event in Las Vegas

Environmental Science Journal References Scott M. Graffius’ Project Management Work

AI Institute of Switzerland Features Scott M. Graffius’ Work on Algorithms

Exotic Team Dynamics: The New Frontier of Human–AI Collaboration

Scott M. Graffius’ Work Featured at ACM DIS ’25

Climbing the Ladder: The Head of Agile/PMO’s Organizational Proximity to the CEO is Closer Than Ever

Harness Sci-Fi and Speculative Design While Embracing Imperfection to Drive Innovation and Proactively Predict and Prepare for the Future

Scott M. Graffius’ “Agile Scrum” Book Featured in a Publication of the Associação Nacional de Educação Católica do Brasil (ANEC)

Setting Direction with OKRs and Tracking Progress with KPIs: A Guide for Agile, Project Management, and Tech Teams

AI Showcase Showdown: Ranking AI Accuracy on Project Management Basics

BookAuthority Features “Agile Scrum” by Scott M. Graffius in “10 Agile Software Development Books That Define the Field”

Exploring Team Dynamics, Adaptability, and Creative Problem-Solving Through Felix the Cat’s Metaphorical Toolkit

Mind Games and Master Plans: How PsyOps Exploit Psychological Phenomena

The “Pants-on-Fire Index for AI”

16 Causes of Technical Debt and How to Avoid It

PMI’s Infinity AI Gets the Basics of Team Development Alarmingly and Repeatedly Wrong

Agile for Unicorns: 7 Keys to Thrive; Scott M. Graffius’ Workshop

Scott M. Graffius’ “Agile Scrum: Your Quick Start Guide with Step-by-Step Instructions” Featured in Prestigious National Academies of Sciences Publication

Meta and Anduril’s EagleEye and the Future of XR: How Gaming, AI, and Agile Are Transforming Defense

"Agile Protocol" and the Power of Satire, Parody, and Humor

AI in Agile: Benefits, Risks, Outlook

Hostinger Highlights Scott M. Graffius’ “Agile Protocol” Book in Feature on Software Projects

French Ministry of Culture Links to Scott M. Graffius Research in Their Guide for Responsible Digital Communication

National Science Foundation’s LTER Network Features Scott M. Graffius’ Phases of Team Development IP

Waterfall vs. Agile: What’s Fixed, What’s Flexible, and Why It Matters

Scott M. Graffius Delivering $2.3 Billion in Value Through AI, Agile, and Project/PMO Leadership

The Problem with Heroes in Agile

The 3 Vital Rules of Science: What They Are and Why They Matter

“Agile Protocol: The Transformation Ultimatum” Lands on the Amazon Best Sellers List!

Scott M. Graffius Recognized as a Top Thought Leader in Digital Disruption by Thinkers360

“Agile Protocol: The Transformation Ultimatum” by Scott M. Graffius Crashes the Book Scene with Satirical Firepower

NCKU in Taiwan Integrates Graffius' 'Phases of Team Development' into Its Curriculum

The Art and Science of Aligning Initiatives with Strategic Objectives

RGPV University Adds Scott M. Graffius’ "Agile Scrum: Your Quick Start Guide with Step-by-Step Instructions" to Its Syllabus

Introducing ‘Engage or Fade: Decoding the Half-Life of Digital Resonance’ – A New Talk by Scott M. Graffius

Dropbox Company (Nira) Taps into Scott M. Graffius’ Expertise in Strategic Planning

Reporting Errors in a Publication: A Case Study on ‘Frontiers in Public Health’

NESEA Conference Session on Innovation Highlights Scott M. Graffius' 'Phases of Team Development'

U.S. Soccer Scores with Scott M. Graffius' Intellectual Property on Teamwork

U.S. Department of Commerce Partner (IEDC) Features Scott M. Graffius’ Intellectual Property

How Long Do Your Posts Live? AI Critiques Scott M. Graffius’ Research on the Half-Life of Social Media

Agile's Journey Through the Decades

Scott M. Graffius' Role in Advancing Project Management Institute (PMI) Standards Excellence

Most Valuable IT Certifications: Update for 2025

The PMI + Agile Alliance Merger: A Recipe for Success?

When Agile, AI, and Strategic Thinking Converge

Scott M. Graffius’ Phases of Team Development: 2025 Update

Lifespan (Half-Life) of Social Media Posts: Update for 2025

Verizon Features Scott M. Graffius

Do Not Read This Article! An Exploration of the Streisand Effect and Other Phenomena

Scott M. Graffius' 'Phases of Team Development' was Spotlighted in Journal of Neurosurgery

Pinterest Japan Uses Graffius’ Research on Temporal Dynamics on Social Media Platforms

Hochschule Coburg (Coburg University) Germany Uses Scott M. Graffius’ Phases of Team Development IP in Coursework on Agile Development

Wild World of Team Dynamics [Updated Two-Minute Video]

EU Europass Teacher Academy Features Scott M. Graffius’ ‘Phases of Team Development’ in Leadership Training

Side-by-Side Comparison of Retrospectives and Hot Washes

Constructor University 2024 Advanced Software Technology Handbook References Scott M. Graffius' Work on Team Dynamics

Strategies for Medical Team Success Featured Scott M. Graffius’ ‘Phases of Team Development’ Intellectual Property

SBG Neumark — Europe’s Largest Distribution Transformer Plant — Powers Up with Scott M. Graffius’ Intellectual Property

Scott M. Graffius’ Intellectual Property was Employed by the NHS — the Largest Single-Payer Healthcare System in Europe

Luxury Unwrapped: The Ultimate Holiday Gift Guide for Every Budget

Singapore Institute of Technology Features Work of Scott M. Graffius

Tufts University Features Scott M. Graffius 'Phases of Team Development' Intellectual Property

'Cat Herders': Retelling the Massive Success Story

Pennsylvania State Agency Used Scott M. Graffius' Intellectual Property

Copyright Infringement in a Book Published by AuthorHouse / Author Solutions / The Najafi Companies: Publisher Fails to Respond or Take Required Action

Pinterest Inc. References Scott M. Graffius’ Research

Bournemouth University Used Scott M. Graffius’ Intellectual Property

‘Comparative Methodological Guidelines: Handbook for Educators’ Violates Scott M. Graffius’ Copyright

Japan Backlog User Group Event Featured Scott M. Graffius’ ‘Phases of Team Development’

TurningWest's 'Trial'

Radio Silence from the American Association of Neurological Surgeons on Report of Blatant Plagiarism in Their ‘Journal of Neurosurgery’ Publication

Supplement to Graffius' 'Lifespan (Half-Life) of Social Media Posts' Research: Typical Engagement Distribution Pattern for Social Media Posts

How Algorithms Shape the User Experience on Social Media Platforms

Thinkers360 Named Scott M. Graffius a Top Thought Leader on Agile

More articles are listed here.





scottgraffius-com-article-sections-v2026-cite-lwres

How to Cite This Article



Graffius, S. M. (2026, November 16). A Critical Analysis of Sage Publications' Author Page for Bruce W. Tuckman. ScottGraffius.com. https://scottgraffius.com/blog/files/critical-analysis-of-sage-publications-author-page-for-bruce-w-tuckman.html





scottgraffius-com-article-sections-v2026-doi-lwres

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)



Coming soon





scottgraffius-com-article-sections-v2026-ackn-lwres

Content Acknowledgements



Names, marks, and content are the property of their respective owners.

"Bruce Wayne Tuckman" page by Sage Publications is the property of Sage Publications.

This article by Scott M. Graffius includes brief excerpts from the page, attributed and used under the fair use doctrine for purposes of news reporting, commentary, and analysis.





scottgraffius-com-article-sections-v2026-tags-hashtags-lwres

Tags and Hashtags



  • Leadership
  • Teamwork
  • Team Development
  • Organizational Behavior
  • Tuckman's Stages of Group Development
  • Adjourning
  • Publishing Standards
  • Academic Publishing
  • Forming - Storming - Norming - Performing - Adjourning

  • #Leadership
  • #Teamwork
  • #Management
  • #Education
  • #Research
  • #TuckmanModel
  • #Adjourning
  • #PublishingStandards
  • #AcademicPublishing
  • #FSNP
  • #FSNPA






scottgraffius-com-article-sections-v2026-notes-lwres

Post-Publication Notes



If there are any supplements or updates to this article after the date of publication, they will appear here.





scottgraffius-com-article-sections-v2026-copyright-lwres

Copyright



Copyright © Scott M. Graffius. All rights reserved.

Content on this site—including text, images, videos, and data—may not be used for training or input into any artificial intelligence, machine learning, or automatized learning systems, or published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without the express written permission of Scott M. Graffius.






custom - back to main page of blog